Garden Club of New Haven
  • Home
  • Who We Are
    • About Us
    • 2013 Tree Project
    • Civic Projects >
      • Community Activities
      • Phelps Triangle Park
    • Club History
    • Community Awards
    • Conservation >
      • Individual Action
      • Birdscaping
      • GCA National Affairs and Legislation and Conservation
      • Water Conservation
    • Holiday Arrangements for Area Nursing Homes
    • Horticulture
    • Leeway
    • New Haven's Green and Its Elms >
      • Walking Tour and DVD of The New Haven Green: Heart of a City
      • Slide Show - GCNH & New Haven's Elms
  • Trees and Power
    • Utility tree pruning and removal >
      • Previous Updates
      • Trees and Power: A Slide Show Summary >
        • Trees & Power >
          • Damages and Penalties for Unauthorized Tree Pruning and Removal
          • Tree Ordinances and Commissions; Tree Warden Permits
        • GCNH Positions on Trees and Power
      • The Benefits of Street Trees
      • Ensure utility compliance with the law
      • Frequently Asked Questions
      • RECENT INFORMATION, NOTICES AND NEWS >
        • Utility Vegetation Management Plans >
          • PURA Appeal
          • Background and Detail: Utility Pruning and Removal >
            • INFORMATION ON PURA DOCKET NO.12-01-10, TREE TRIMMING
            • Legislative Actions
            • List of Documents
            • News Coverage
            • ACTIONS YOU CAN TAKE >
              • Alternatives to ETT/ETR and Rigid Line Clearance Standards
              • Diagram for Local Action
            • Petitions, Meetings on Utility Tree Removal and Pruning
          • PHOTOS
        • Undergrounding of Wires -- A long term solution
      • Wood Products from Removed Trees
      • Summary of the Law-2017
  • Flowers, Plants & Gardens
    • Garden History and Design
    • Partners for Plants
  • Members
    • Index
    • News
    • President's Monthly Letter
    • Board Meeting Minutes
    • General Meeting Minutes
    • 2020-2021 Directory
    • Complete calendar and listing of monthly program
    • Flower Shows, Garden Tours, Lectures and Movies
    • General Information: Articles of Association and Bylaws >
      • Club Project Proposal Form
      • Membership Requirements
      • Dues
      • Board
      • Endowed Funds
      • Past Presidents
      • Strategic Plan
    • Committees A-L >
      • Archives
      • Awards
      • Civic
      • Communications
      • Conservation
      • Finance
      • Floral Design
      • Garden History & Design
      • Horticulture
      • Hospitality
    • Committees M-Z >
      • Membership
      • New Member Education
      • Nominating
      • Phelps Triangle
      • Photography
      • Scholarship
      • Trees and Power >
        • Background and News Coverage March 5 and 6 PURA Meetings
        • Planting the Right Trees in the Right Place
      • Visiting Gardens >
        • Past Garden Visits
        • Members Gardens
      • Ways and Means
    • Photos Premiere-The New Haven Green: Heart of a City
    • Annual Meeting Photos >
      • 2012 Annual Meeting
      • 2013 Annual Meeting
      • 2015 Annual meeting
      • 2016 Annual Meeting
      • 2017 Annual Meeting
      • 2018 Annual Meeting
    • GCA News >
      • GCA contact info
      • GCA Founders Fund
      • The Redwoods and GCA
    • The Federated Garden Clubs of America
Updated January 15, 2021
Picture
Utility Pruning and Removal of Street/Roadside Trees
  Contact: GCNHtreesandpower@gmail.com

PURA Final Decision: UI's Targeted Risk Management program limited
.


On January 13, 2020 the Public Utilities Regulatory Authority ("PURA") issued a  Final Decision in Docket No. 18-12-25 that directed United Illuminating to modify its Targeted Risk Management (TRM) program:  [T]he TRM program shall not be used as an alternative or replacement to UPZ [pruning] to achieve tree line clearance for 4 to 5 years.  In summary, the Authority concludes that subsection (e) of Conn. Gen. Stat. 16-234 only authorizes an electric distribution company to perform vegetation management where there is direct contact and visible signs of burning and that only the minimum level of pruning be done to resolve the offense." (See link to full Final Decision below for details and other issues addressed.)  GCNH argued for such an interpretation of subsection (e) in comments made to PURA.  Eversource must also comply with this interpretation when it does direct contact pruning pursuant to subsection (e). 

Under this decision, United Illuminating cannot continue to use TRM to avoid the normal requirements of the law that it obtain a permit from municipal tree wardens and notify abutting property owners before pruning or removing trees within the Utility Protection Zone (UPZ) surrounding its electric distribution wires. 

GCNH documents filed with PURA in 18-12-25 and three news articles about the issue are also below. (Note that the docket number on the first two comments should be 18-12-25, not 18-25-12.)

final_decision181225-011321.pdf
File Size: 515 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

gcnh_comments-docket_no._18-25-12.pdf
File Size: 110 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

gcnh_second_comments-docket_no._18-25-12.pdf
File Size: 134 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

hamden_orders_ui_to_stop_cutting_trees_-_ctinsider.com.pdf
File Size: 166 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

register_1-12-20.pdf
File Size: 575 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

gcnh_comments_on_answers_to_interrogatories-docket_no._18-12-25.pdf
File Size: 126 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

hamden_protects_trees_from_chainsaws___new_haven_independent.pdf
File Size: 445 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

What you can do to protect your trees, especially from unnecessary direct contact pruning:  Take photos ASAP of your street trees to have a dated record of their condition. Make note of your position and angle, and, if pruning occurs, take a photo from the same position and angle to document any violation of the law.   If there is direct contact between electric distribution wires (the highest wires) and your street trees, be especially alert.  You may want to inform your electric distribution company of the contact, and then make sure that it prunes only to remove that contact by being present when pruning take place.  Get their commitment, in writing if possible, that they will not prune without your presence.  File a complaint with PURA if UI (or Eversource) violates the law by pruning or removing a tree without following the proper permit and notice requirements.  Also  file a complaint with UI or Eversource, and with your tree warden and chief elected official (mayor, first selectman).    
Flow Chart of Legal Requirements

 Summary of Connecticut Law on Utility Vegetation Management
revised January 2017

 Greenwich Tree Conservancy Brochure:  "What are My Tree Rights Relating to Public Utilities"
(The Conservancy welcomes its use as a model for brochures by other towns and organizations.)        
   GCNH Flyer for distribution in your town or city:  "Protect Your Community's Street Trees"
flyer_for_distribution.pdf
File Size: 1313 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

DEEP Interactive Map with Contact Information for Your Town or City's Tree Warden

List of Tree Wardens in Every CT City, Town or Borough (See this for borough, village and deputy tree wardens)

PURA Final Decision:  Report to General Assembly on Utility Vegetation Management Practices   PURA required the utilities to bring their notices to property owners into compliance with explicit statutory requirements now.  However, the decision allows the utilities to ask tree wardens for permits to prune or remove trees according to rigid line clearance standards, such as ETT, without evaluating and specifying which trees need to be pruned or removed (often referred to as a "blanket permit").  PURA recognized the authority of tree wardens to require evaluation and justification of pruning and removal by the utilities prior to issuing  permits and to otherwise regulate such work, but, if a tree warden does not exercise his/her authority, it falls to property owners alone to object or request a modification.  If some property owners in a community do not understand the loss of benefits, including reduced property values, that unnecessary removal of mature trees can cause, all property owners will be harmed.  




Recent Information, Notices and News (including PURA Decisions)
(updated 7/2/2015)

Frequently Asked Questions
(updated 3/16/2015)


Background 
(Documents,
Prior Statutes, Past Meetings)
All News Coverage

Slide Show on Trees and Power (updated March 30, 2014; not revised)


Protect Trees in Your Neighborhood and in Your City, Town or Borough from Improper Pruning and Unnecessary Removal
[Actions You Can Take]

Summary of CT Law on Utility Vegetation Management & 
PURA Final Decisions

Tree Ordinances and Commissions; Tree Warden Permits

Comprehensive Overview: Protecting Neighborhood and Other Roadside Trees; Strategies for Community Leaders and Residents,
a publication of the Connecticut Fund for the Environment.


Utility Vegetation Management Plans, including Illustrations of ETT, Photos and Video of Fairfield Public Meeting with UI
Protect Trees On and Abutting Your Property: permits, notices, objections and requests for modification

Filing an Appeal with PURA from a Tree Warden or DOT Decision

Damages and Fines/Penalties for Unauthorized Pruning and Removal of Trees and Shrubs

Alternatives to  Rigid Line Clearance Standards

GCNH Positions
on Trees and Power
(including Right Tree/Right Place Trees)


The Benefits of Street/Roadside
Trees

(updated 3/16//2015)

Undergrounding of Wires

Wood Products from Removed Trees
CONTACT:  GCNHtreesandpower@gmail.com to ask questions, share information or arrange interviews regarding utility pruning and removal.  Let us know immediately if a utility prunes or removes without a permit from a tree warden (town roads) or the DOT (state highways), fails to provide legally required notice, prunes or removes a tree or shrub while an objection or request for modification is pending, or prunes or removes a tree outside of the public right-of-way without the private property owner or municipal owner's consent. ​
For TECHNICAL ISSUES ABOUT THE WEBSITE only, contact gardenclubnh2@gmail.com .
Any discussion of law on this site is for informational purposes only, and does not constitute legal advice. For legal advice regarding particular facts and circumstances, please consult an attorney. 
Click here to install Adobe Reader for free, in order to read PDF files.
Updated August 15, 2017